How an open vented cylinder and the loft tanks fit together
Two tanks, two jobs — don't mix them up
An open vented system almost always has two tanks side by side in the loft, and the single most common mistake is treating them as interchangeable. They aren't: one feeds drinking and washing water, the other feeds only the heating circuit, and nothing should cross between them.
The bigger one is the cold water storage cistern: it gravity-feeds the cold taps, the shower and the cylinder's cold side. The smaller one next to it is the feed and expansion tank, usually sold as a “Fortic” tank: it feeds and vents the sealed-off heating loop only, and never supplies a tap.
- Cold water cistern — bigger, feeds taps and the cylinder's cold feed.
- F&E tank — smaller, feeds and vents the central heating circuit only.
- Each has its own float valve, its own feed pipe, and its own vent or overflow. None of that is shared between them.
The F&E tank: feed and expansion, nothing else
On a sealed (pressurised) boiler, thermal expansion is absorbed by an expansion vessel and let off by a pressure relief valve. An open vented system has neither: instead, the heating water simply has somewhere open to expand into — the F&E tank — and a vent pipe that can never be valved shut.
The vent pipe rises off the heating flow near the boiler, usually in 22 mm, and runs up into the loft where it bends over and discharges into the F&E tank. As the water heats and expands, the level in the tank rises a little and the vent lets any air or steam escape; as it cools, the tank tops the circuit back up through its own float valve. That float valve should be fed by its own small-bore pipe — not spliced into the cold water cistern's supply, which would let heating-circuit water (often carrying corrosion inhibitor) find its way toward drinking water if anything backed up.
Never fit a valve of any kind on the vent pipe. It is the safety device for the whole heating circuit — doing the job a relief valve does on a sealed system — and a closed vent turns the boiler into an unvented pressure vessel with no outlet.
The cold water cistern and its vent pipe
The cold water cistern is the one that actually supplies water people use: it gravity-feeds the bathroom taps and shower, and feeds the cold side of the cylinder below it. Head height is what drives pressure here — roughly 0.1 bar per metre the tank sits above the tap, which is why loft tanks are built as high as the roof allows and why gravity showers are famously weak on a single-storey extension.
The cylinder's hot side also has its own open vent pipe, separate from the heating vent: it rises from the top of the cylinder and bends over — not into — the cold water cistern. It's there for exactly the same reason as the heating vent: an open escape route for the hot water side, so the cylinder can never become a sealed pressure vessel. Two open pipes dropping into (or over) two different tanks in the same loft is normal, not a fault.
- Cistern ball valve (float valve) — tops the tank up from the rising main.
- Overflow/warning pipe — wider bore, set just above the normal water line, terminating outside somewhere you'll notice it dripping. It's not the vent: the vent carries air from the system, the overflow only runs when the float valve has already failed.
- Cold feed to the cylinder, and separately to the bathroom — each should have its own isolating valve so one can be worked on without draining the whole tank.
Direct vs indirect cylinder: what changes downstairs
A direct cylinder has no coil: it's heated only by an immersion heater, and its pipework is just the cold feed from the cistern, the vent pipe looped over the cistern, and the hot draw-off to the taps. There's no connection to the boiler at all.
An indirect cylinder has all of that, plus a coil inside connected to the boiler's primary circuit — flow and return pipes fed and vented by the F&E tank, not the cold cistern. The coil heats the stored water without mixing the two circuits: heating water (with inhibitor) stays in the coil and never reaches the water you wash in.
| Direct cylinder | Indirect cylinder | |
|---|---|---|
| Heat source | Immersion heater only | Boiler primary circuit via an internal coil, usually with an immersion as backup |
| Connected to | Cold cistern only | Cold cistern (secondary) and F&E tank (primary, through the boiler) |
| Vent pipe | One, over the cold cistern | Two: one over the cold cistern (secondary), one over the F&E tank (primary) |
If the boiler side has no cylinder-ready three-way valve, the primary circuit needs its own pump on the coil branch and check valves on the parallel branches — the same logic as a sealed-system indirect cylinder, just fed and vented by the F&E tank instead of a pressure vessel.
Common mistakes
No tanks in your loft at all?
If there's no F&E tank and no cold water cistern feeding the cylinder, you're not on an open vented system — you're on a sealed, mains-pressure setup instead, where a DHW expansion vessel and a pressure relief valve do the job the loft tanks do here.
Common questions
What is an F&E tank for?
Feed and expansion. It tops the central heating circuit up through its own float valve and gives the heating water somewhere to expand into as it heats, via an open vent pipe that must never be valved shut. It never supplies a tap — that's the cold water cistern's job.
What's the difference between a direct and indirect cylinder?
A direct cylinder is heated only by an immersion heater and has no connection to the boiler. An indirect cylinder has a coil inside, fed by the boiler's primary circuit (via the F&E tank), that heats the stored water without mixing the two circuits.
Why are there two tanks and two vent pipes in my loft?
The bigger tank is the cold water cistern, feeding taps and the cylinder's cold side, with its own vent pipe looped over it from the cylinder. The smaller tank is the F&E tank, feeding and venting only the heating circuit. They're kept separate so heating-circuit water never reaches drinking water.
Can I convert an open vented system to a sealed one?
Yes — it's a common upgrade, replacing the loft tanks with a pressure relief valve and a DHW expansion vessel on a sealed cylinder or combi, and a separate expansion vessel on the heating side. It's worth doing properly rather than partially: see the mains-pressure layout on this site's water heater piping guide.